RECYCLING · BUFFALO AREA

Top 8 Recycling Centers in Buffalo, NY (2026)

We ranked 8 recycling businesses in the Buffalo area that have at least 10 Google reviews, out of 15 we list. Ratings adjusted for review count, so a few glowing reviews can't beat a long track record.

Ratings and review counts from Google as of October 8, 2026.

  1. 1
    Geiter Done Green Waste Facility
    ★ 4.9 10 Google reviews · Buffalo
  2. 2
    Bottle Bank Redemption Center
    ★ 4.5 23 Google reviews · Buffalo
  3. 3
    Metalico South Park
    ★ 4.3 52 Google reviews · Buffalo
  4. 4
    Buffalo Computer Recycling, Llc.
    ★ 4.5 15 Google reviews · Buffalo
    USDOT-registered carrier
  5. 5
    Buffalo Recycling Enterprises, Llc
    ★ 4.4 20 Google reviews · Buffalo
  6. 6
    Surface Finishing Systems
    ★ 3.9 11 Google reviews · Buffalo
  7. 7
    Westside Value Redemption
    ★ 3.5 17 Google reviews · Buffalo
  8. 8
    Bailey Ave Bottle & Can Redemption Center
    ★ 3.2 11 Google reviews · Buffalo

Get quotes from recycling businesses

Free for buyers. Tell us what you need and where, and we'll follow up to help you find a provider.

Request quotes

How we rank

  • Score: Google rating, weighted by number of reviews. Every business starts from a neutral 4.0 and its reviews move the score, so a rating backed by few reviews counts for less.
  • To be ranked: at least 10 Google reviews, listed as a recycling business on Google, and located within about 40 km of central Buffalo.
  • Badges never change a score. USDOT registration and our verified-listing badge are shown for information. Many good small businesses aren't in those registries.
  • No paid placement. Claiming a listing is free and adds details, not points.

Full method: methodology. Found a mistake? Email [email protected].

Top-rated recycling elsewhere in New York

Looking for every listed business, not just the top 10? Browse all of Buffalo.

Frequently asked

How is this list ranked?

By each business's Google rating, adjusted for how many reviews it has: every business starts from a neutral 4.0, and its real reviews pull the score up or down, so a rating from a handful of reviews counts for less than one backed by hundreds. That way a 4.9 from 10 reviews doesn't outrank a 4.7 from 400. Businesses need at least 10 Google reviews to be ranked.

Can a business pay to rank higher?

No. Claiming a listing (free) adds a logo, description and a verified-listing badge, but no points. Badges such as USDOT registration are shown for information and never change a score. The only way to move up is more and better customer reviews.

Which area does "Buffalo" cover?

Businesses whose address is within about 40 km (25 miles) of central Buffalo, so nearby suburbs are included. Each business's own city is shown next to its name.

Something is wrong or missing. How do I report it?

Email [email protected] with the business name and what needs fixing. If it's your business, you can claim the listing for free and correct its details yourself.