Home / Reports / Waste Hauler Scorecard 2026

REPORT · 9 STATES

Waste Hauler Scorecard 2026: How the Big Trash Companies Rate in 9 States

US Waste Index · Version 1.0 · Published November 12, 2026 · Reviewer: not independently reviewed by a third party

Google listings collected July 21, 2026 to October 22, 2026 · Download the data (CSV) · Reuse: Data Licensing

We matched 1,564 rated trash-collection locations in California, New York, Florida, Texas, Ohio, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and North Carolina to the company that runs them, then compared 95,813 Google reviews. 215 of those locations belong to named waste companies; the rest are independent haulers and city or county services. Waste Pro rates highest and GFL Environmental lowest.

Key findings

  1. Waste Pro rates highest and GFL Environmental lowest of the 6 companies we could score. GFL Environmental averages 1.85 stars across 728 reviews at 16 rated locations in 5 states. Waste Pro averages 4.68 stars across 13,733 reviews at 6 rated locations in 3 states. Only companies with at least 5 rated locations are scored.
  2. 9 of GFL Environmental's 12 locations with 10 or more reviews rate under 3 stars. Counting only locations with 10 or more reviews, 75% of GFL Environmental's, 67.2% of Republic Services', 24.7% of WM's and 0% of Waste Connections' rate below 3 stars, against 13.4% of independent haulers.
  3. WM, Republic Services and GFL Environmental rate below local independent haulers. Independent trash haulers average 4.01 stars across 1,309 rated locations, and city and county sanitation services 3.78. Waste Pro, Rumpke and Waste Connections rate higher than independents.
  4. Republic Services rates below WM in 7 of the 9 states where both have at least 3 rated locations. In Florida the two are within 0.1 stars of each other. Republic Services rates higher in Illinois (3.64 against 3.45).

The scorecard

Companies with at least 5 rated trash-collection locations, highest rated first, with independents and public services for comparison.

Waste Pro 4.68
Rumpke 4.35
Waste Connections 4.19
WM 3.75
Republic Services 2.71
GFL Environmental 1.85
Independent haulers 4.01
OperatorStatesRated locationsReviewsRating (weighted) Locations with 10+ reviewsMedian of thoseShare of those under 3★
Waste Pro 3 6 13,733 4.68 6 4.75 0%
Rumpke 1 8 6,045 4.35 7 4.30 0%
Waste Connections 4 6 1,731 4.19 6 4.20 0%
WM 9 85 15,741 3.75 81 3.60 24.7%
Republic Services 9 82 4,508 2.71 58 2.70 67.2%
GFL Environmental 5 16 728 1.85 12 1.95 75%
Independent haulers 9 1,309 50,680 4.01 558 4.40 13.4%
City and county services 8 40 1,603 3.78 31 4.00 16.1%

The weighted rating is the average star across all reviews, so locations with many reviews count for more. The median shows the typical location instead. Also matched, but with fewer than 5 rated locations so not scored: Recology (4), Meridian Waste (3), Burrtec (2), Athens Services (1), Casella (1) and EDCO (1).

State by state

Weighted rating in each state, with the number of rated locations in brackets.

OperatorCANYFLTXOHILPAGANC
Waste Pro ··4.69 (4)····4.20 (1)4.80 (1)
Rumpke ····4.35 (8)····
Waste Connections ·4.10 (1)3.50 (2)4.17 (2)····4.30 (1)
WM 4.05 (15)3.84 (6)3.84 (20)3.42 (16)3.64 (6)3.45 (5)2.87 (5)3.51 (7)3.22 (5)
Republic Services 2.34 (21)2.06 (4)3.82 (7)2.56 (18)2.12 (7)3.64 (9)2.30 (6)2.22 (3)3.05 (7)
GFL Environmental ··3.38 (4)4.70 (1)·1.13 (2)·1.68 (2)1.68 (7)
Independent haulers 4.29 (285)4.24 (199)3.66 (136)3.91 (276)3.86 (89)4.16 (66)4.12 (72)3.95 (83)4.05 (103)
City and county services 3.72 (2)4.31 (9)3.21 (4)3.61 (18)3.85 (2)3.70 (1)·4.30 (1)3.94 (3)

Grey cells have fewer than 3 rated locations and are not used in state comparisons. A dot means no rated location in our directory for that state. CA = California, NY = New York, FL = Florida, TX = Texas, OH = Ohio, IL = Illinois, PA = Pennsylvania, GA = Georgia and NC = North Carolina.

Methodology

  • Locations: every trash-collection listing in the US Waste Index directory for California, New York, Florida, Texas, Ohio, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia and North Carolina, plus any other listing for a named company (its landfills, transfer stations and recycling plants, which customers also review). Listings come from Google Maps searches in each state's metro areas between July 21, 2026 and October 22, 2026. Each Google listing counts once.
  • Companies: matched on exact brand names ("WM -", "Republic Services", "GFL", "Waste Pro of …"), not on words like "waste management" that unrelated businesses and city departments also use. Franchise and acquired brands that still trade under another name are counted as independent.
  • Ratings: weighted by review count, so a 5-star location with one review can't outweigh a 3-star location with 300. Locations with no reviews are left out.
  • Limits: Google ratings reflect the customers who choose to leave reviews, and people tend to review trash service when something goes wrong. Our directory covers the metros we have searched, so it holds some of each company's locations, not all of them, and fewer in states where we have searched fewer metros. A few locations with thousands of reviews can carry a company's weighted rating, which is why the median is shown alongside it.

State-level detail is in the Texas, California, Florida, New York and Ohio reports. The full figures are in the CSV. For questions or to use these numbers, see Contact and Data Licensing.

Changelog

  • v1.0 (November 12, 2026): Initial publication.